Page 1 of Alternative Endings - Worthwhile or just thrown in for fun?

General Forum

Alternative Endings - Worthwhile or just thrown in for fun?

daveo (Competent) posted this on Thursday, 24th May 2001, 10:33

I`m all for having a feature packed DVD with various extra bits and pieces, but what gets my goat is so called "alternative endings". From the few DVDs I have seen it`s been a pretty mixed bag.

For example, Ronin - a good alternative ending, shame it wasn`t properly transposed to full film quality.

Final Destination - hmmmm, how bizarre, but at least it was filmed and edited.

Seven (R1) - On the second disc, oooh alternative ending - what a dissapointment - story board, why? They didn`t even shoot this ending, doesn`t that mean something.

Arlington Road - 10 minutes of the director ranting on (like I am here) about how they didn`t want a sequel and blah blah blah blah blah.

but I have decided that alternative endings are pretty much a waste of time, unless they turn the story on its head.

Anyone else share my view?

RE: Alternative Endings - Worthwhile or just thrown in for fun?

ickle yoda (Competent) posted this on Thursday, 24th May 2001, 12:03

I actually quite like alternative endings.

Some are rubbish and disappointing such as region 1 version of seven, I was looking forward to something special there. Although not massively different, both terminator films have quite ok different endings, expanding on the story slightly. They abyss also has a much better ending than the original in many peoples views. I agree they can be disappointing but no more so than featurettes and interviews which can turn out to simply be a bunch of clips strewn together. Worst still is outtakes such as charlies angels when the outtakes are already at the credits doh!!

I dont think things like the outakes for charlies angels should be considered an extra as they are already on the standard copy of the film. What does everyone else think

Go back to General Forum threads, or All Forum threads