Latest Forum Posts
[VIDEO] Star Wars: The Acolyte
last post by Pete-MK
Arsenal 23/24 season
last post by RJS
The Responder
last post by admars
Boris the not-a-spider
last post by Jitendar Canth
[VIDEO] Eric
last post by Pete-MK
Duane Eddy RIP
last post by marksparks999
Reviewer Euros Pool anyone?
last post by mbilko
The All New Doctor Who Thread...
last post by Jitendar Canth
How many browsers do you use?
last post by admars
The Speccy reborn
last post by Jitendar Canth
[VIDEO] Star Wars: Ahsoka
last post by Par Mizan

Page 1 of [VIDEO] Society of the Snow (Netflix)

DVDs & Films Forum

[VIDEO] Society of the Snow (Netflix)

Gareth Williams (Elite) posted this on Tuesday, 9th January 2024, 23:55



A fresh re-telling of the story of the 1972 Andes plane disaster, previously featued in the 1993 film Alive (which the real-life survivors refer to as the "Disney version").

I've been fascinated by this story for a long time and read the book on which Alive was based some years ago. I was surprised by how much the film left out or glossed over. The true story was even more harrowing than the film made out and it remains one of the most astounding feats of human endurance.

This version, directed by JA Bayona (The Impossible), is considerably more accurate and was made with the cooperation of the remaining survivors. It also features a race-appropriate cast of mostly newcomers and was partly filmed at the actual crash site.

Anyway, it's really, really good and as you might expect, pretty gruelling.



Thanks from: RJS sj

RE: [VIDEO] Society of the Snow (Netflix)

RJS (undefined) posted this on Wednesday, 10th January 2024, 09:21

I wasn't sure if I wanted to watch this story again, but I didn't realise the Alive movie was the Disney version so now I'm tempted after your recommendation!


Editor
MYREVIEWER.COM

My Flickr Photostream

RE: [VIDEO] Society of the Snow (Netflix)

sj (Elite) posted this on Saturday, 13th January 2024, 11:40

Watched this yesterday. It was much better than Alive I thought and using a race-appropriate cast added somewhat to the authenticity. However, I'm not totally sure it added too much from the 'original' and quite a bit of it seemed shot for shot the same as I remembered. Both films steer clear somewhat from the real horror of what they did and I'm totally OK with that, eating what looked like chicken and seeing a rib cage right at the end is more than enough. The ending of this was much better than alive. The stone throwing scene accurate and the physical condition of the survivors much more accurately portrayed than in the shiny Hollywood gloss of Alive..
Maybe another 5 or 10 minutes or credits information would have added something lacking from Alive too. What happened next? How did family, friends and the media react to what happened? How were they themselves psychologically? etc..

Ste



We will pay the price but we will not count the cost..

Liked by: RJS

Go back to DVDs & Films Forum threads, or All Forum threads