About This Item

Preview Image for Thunderbirds - Complete Series (Blu-Ray)
Thunderbirds - Complete Series (Blu-Ray) (Blu-ray Details)

Unique ID Code: 0000107976
Added by: Stuart McLean
Added on: 20/9/2008 10:58
View Changes

Other Reviews, etc
  • Log in to Add Reviews, Videos, Etc
  • Places to Buy

    Searching for products...

    Thunderbirds - The Complete Series (Blu-Ray)

    5 / 10

    Oh dear! This review is something of a schizophrenic experience. I'm a huge Thunderbirds fan. I was five years old when it hit the screens in '66 and had already been 'conditioned' by Fireball XL5 and Stingray. After years of relying on either distant memories of the show, or occasional 'cult cinema' showings of the movies, I was first in line for the VHS releases when they revived interest in the series in the early eighties. Then there was that 'deal' with Carlton that brought it back on to our screens in the late eighties / early nineties when a whole new generation of fans emerged. Then came the Carlton DVD's - decent transfers but with frustratingly 'reworked' soundtracks with extra effects that drowned out dialogue on occasion. And that's been it …until now!

    Unlike much period TV, 'Thunderbirds' was produced on 35MM so always had the lovely saturated look of Technicolor movies. So it's one of the few cult / vintage TV series that is worth upgrading to Blu-Ray. I requested a sample disc, and got a single disc on the understanding that I returned it pronto. Apparently there's a queue of salivating middle-aged journalists desperate to get their hands on this much anticipated release.

    So is it worth getting excited about - or spending circa £100 on for the 6 disc set? Well, yes - and no.

    The picture quality is, frankly, stunning. It's a beautiful, deep and detailed transfer where, given the quality, displays all the strings in a way that you will never have seen them before. The richness of the colour and detail is amongst the best high definition TV pieces I've seen. BUT …(and it's a big but) …in a misguided effort to pander to a supposed new audience, the image has been cropped to be displayed as 16:9. There may well have been some judicious panning and scanning but the net result is a general loss of headroom which, once noticed, cannot be ignored. What an opportunity lost! All the effort to get such a fine transfer brutalised by a misguided marketing team. Sadly, this will badly affect sales and will be a decision that ITV DVD will inevitably regret.

    It's also something of a disappointment that the soundtrack seems to be the Carlton DVD re-work which added 'louder explosions' to the original, spoiling to an extent the already fine soundtrack.

    There's a chance that Gerry Anderson was party to this. In the interview I did with him a couple of years back he revealed a misguided dislike for his previous work and likes to grab the opportunity to 'update' where he can. As a result we've seen release of 'Captain Scarlet' with added 80's laser gun effects, a whole new soundtrack on 'Dick Spanner' and a number of re-workings to original soundtracks, like this 'Thunderbirds' one.

    Overall - 'Thunderbirds' as a series, in my view, cannot be faulted. Perhaps a little slow moving for today's viewers, it nonetheless stands for repeated viewings and seems to still capture the attention in hour long episodes; quite a feat for a puppet show!. This release shows just how wonderful the original 35mm material was, and when ITV DVD realise that cropping is tantamount to butchery, and release the discs properly, it will be well worth picking up. But until that time, I'd give this a miss.

    Your Opinions and Comments

    There was a lot of pre-release speculation about this release - whether it would be vertically cropped or "windowboxed" - the sides of the picture filled in with black bars. The latter treatment was given (ISTR) to the HD transfer of Space:1999 that Granada Ventures had BBC Resources prepare for their HD transmission tests. The masters were also used to prepare the SD DVDs from Network.

    It's a crying shame that ITVDVD has chosen to "upgrade" the series in this way. It's beginning to look as though TV releases on Blu might be the reverse of feature film releases on VHS back in the 1980s - ruined for the sake of aspect ratio-ists (temperance nazis - they hate black bars).
    posted by Mark Oates on 20/9/2008 14:07
    You're right. And normally I can live with it...I just won't buy them. But this particular outing is a crying shame because, putting the cropping to one side, this is a fantastic transfer. Almost breath-takingly good. As I was short of time this week, and the PR company wanted the disc back quickly, I actually viewed the disc in a local Sony shop (Windsor) and we took it through its paces on the best kit in town. It caused quite a stir as a couple of the staff there feasted their eyes on the quality of the transfer. A real wow. But with all the framing gone to pot (the hood doesn't look the same with the top of his scalp cut off like a boiled egg) there's absolutely no point in trading up. What a shame!
    posted by Stuart McLean on 20/9/2008 14:46